A forum member posted about this manga series and recommended it with such enthusiasm that I started the series within a few days. To be honest, I was planning on staying away from any further series by this artist/author duo. Why? Well I read Death Note (their previous work as a team) and I’m one of those fans that wished it had ended at the halfway point. I thought that end point would have been A LOT better than where the series ended up. If you’ve read/seen Death Note you know exactly where I mean. But even though the series didn’t go in the direction I wanted it to…I can’t deny the obsessive hold it had over me for the first 7 volumes. So this recommendation from a fellow fan (and some bubbling curiosity about the extreme change in story genre from what Death Note was) pushed me to try their newest series.
Plot Summary
Bakuman follows the story of high school student Moritaka Mashiro, who doesn’t know what he wants to do with his future. One day he draws a picture of Miho Azuki , a girl he is secretly fond of. During class he forgets the notebook at school. He comes back to find that his classmate Akito Takagi (the class genuis) is waiting for him with his notebook. Takagi tries to convince Mashiro to become a mangaka, manga artist, with him. Mashiro’s childhood dream was to draw manga for a living but, his Uncle was a mangaka who had only one successful series before he died in obscurity. His end and the overwhelming odds against success hold Mashiro back. However, Takagi gets Mashiro, and tells Azuki that he and Mashiro are aiming to be mangaka. Mashiro then learns that she wants to be a seiyū, a voice actor, despite the same overwhelming odds of success in that industry. Seeing so many others willing to gamble on their dreams makes Mashiro agrees to also follow his childhood dream.
Art
I’m the type that adores this mangaka’s art style. It’s unique compared to other Shonen, and has a lot more realism to it than most other series. I spend longer on each panel of this series than most others just because of how many details there are to take in and admire. I find myself attracted to every series drawn by Takeshi Obata.
Characters
Every character feels realistic, they’re sometimes unpredictable and have moments of weakness/strength that reflects how a typical person might react. Bakuman has a strong hold over me mainly because I’m VERY attached to the characters. I can’t remember the last time I’ve been on the edge of my seat trying to cheer on the protagonists this much, and they’re not even fighting for their lives! They’re fighting to be mangakas!
Story
When you read the story, you just know that the mangaka duo aren’t making any guarantees on the success and happiness of its characters. That lack of a “safe feeling” is what makes this series far more addicting than other Shonen series that cradle me. Also, I’ve never been a mangaka of Shonen Jump, put the way they portray the inner workings seems EXTREMELY honest and realistic. They go so far as to drop the names of the most famous Shonen mangaka out right now, and even have them currently running in Shonen Jump with our fictional protagonists. At the very least it’s the most detailed/educational series I’ve read about aspiring mangakas so far. I sometimes like to think that I have an understanding of how the world of anime/manga works, but this series has definitely re-educated me.
There was a reason I’ve been mentioning Death Note in this review, as I read this series I get an overwhelming feeling that this mangaka duo are channeling a lot of their experiences from trying to get Death Note (specifically) published in Shonen Jump. They even reference Death Note (as a series) several times in the first few pages, it’s almost as if they want to plant that seed in the reader’s mind so they make comparisons as they read on. Also it’s interesting to note that the author Tsugumi Ohba is unknown to the public. Ohba’s real identity (and gender) is a closely guarded secret.
This series is GREAT! It blows away all other series with stories about characters aspriring to make it in the manga/anime industry. If you don’t believe me on how great this series is, look at how highly it’s ranked in Japan. My little review here is a pathetically small drop in the bucket of all the praise that is out there for Bakuman. This series has been licensed for U.S. release, I’ve already pre-ordered volume 1. So if you don’t want to read online scans you’ll still get your chance to read this series officially released. An anime was also announced to air in the fall of 2010.







#1 by bluedrakon on February 22, 2010 - 7:06 pm
Quote
I agree that Death Note went on longer than it should. This is not my normal stuff to read, but let me know what you think after the first couple volumes!
#2 by xJAYMANx on February 22, 2010 - 9:24 pm
Quote
[Caution: Some minor "Death Note" and "Gurren Lagaan" spoilerage.]
@Duckie-chan: Hmm, I understand what you mean about “Death Note”, but on the other hand, I can also see that the story had to follow its natural arc or progression. The Western tendency is to end a film or story right after the climactic duel or battle, ending at the top of the arc, right? But I don’t necessary accept the typical Western ending…
I mean, should “Gurren Lagann” have stopped (right after the first climactic battle) without fast-forwarding 7 years? Just as “Death Note” fast-forwarded 5 years? Hmm, some food for thought, hehe. ^_~
#3 by lovelyduckie on February 23, 2010 - 1:23 pm
Quote
@ blue – I’m 75 Chapters into this series. It’s great, one of my current favorites.
@ Jay – I like what TTGL did, that’s what made THAT particular series truly amazing. For Death Note it’s also possible that my admiration for L left a very high standard to meet, and Near and Mello (even combined) just didn’t meet his level for me. But you’re right I suppose it could have been a cultural thing.
#4 by AS on February 23, 2010 - 7:56 pm
Quote
Gahh, you beat me to the review lol. Bakuman is now one of my favorite mangas. The art style and storyline is great. I’m not exactly sure if what is depicted is accurate in terms of how Shonen Jump works but if it is then it’s really cool to learn the inside of the industry. I can’t wait for the anime lol. It is “pretty big” in the manga to get an anime after all lol.
#5 by Yi on February 26, 2010 - 8:24 pm
Quote
This looks really great. I enjoyed Death Note and I think I will probably enjoy this as well, especially for its art style. Further, it would definitely be quite interesting to see all the allusions they make to publishing Death Note.
#6 by Merilee on August 17, 2010 - 3:13 pm
Quote
I would’ve loved this series if the authors could tone down the MISOGYNY. Just a little bit.
#7 by renx on December 11, 2010 - 11:07 am
Quote
I hope more people will be reading this and learn to treasure how hard it is for mangaka to create a story. It is ok to read them online but do buy them as a way to support their hard work.
Pingback: On Order: Nendoroid Takagi Akito and Mashiro Moritaka « Lovelyduckie’s Blog
#8 by Mike D. Burke on January 11, 2011 - 7:20 pm
Quote
Hey I’m a huge fan of Bakuman and other such amazing graphic novels as well would you mind posting a link on your blog here to a review I wrote on it? I’m actually a comic book reviewer for the Syracuse edition of examiner.com. Thanks, let me know.
#9 by lovelyduckie on January 14, 2011 - 7:49 am
Quote
sure
#10 by Ro on December 9, 2012 - 11:31 pm
Quote
LOL yeah Merilee. I love this manga, but when it came to those parts (SPOILER) about “how a girl should act nice, generous, and kind” and “something a woman can never understand” just made me roll my eyes. Not that a girl shouldn’t be nice kind and generous. I just didn’t appreciate the little boxes/categories they put azuki into…